Hiển thị các bài đăng có nhãn guilty. Hiển thị tất cả bài đăng
Hiển thị các bài đăng có nhãn guilty. Hiển thị tất cả bài đăng

Thứ Hai, 6 tháng 5, 2013

Truck driver not guilty over cyclist's death

Luke Michael Stevens

Luke Michael Stevens walks from court on Monday after the not guilty verdict. Source: The Courier-Mail

Richard Pollett

Gifted musician Richard Pollett died after being struck by a cement truck's rear tyres as the driver attempted to overtake him on Moggill Rd in September 2011. Source: The Courier-Mail

A CEMENT truck driver accused of driving dangerously and causing the death of cyclist and gifted musician Richard Pollett has been found not guilty.

The jury retired on Friday morning to consider its verdict after three days of evidence and submissions in the District Court trial in Brisbane, where driver Luke Michael Stevens, 29, pleaded not guilty to dangerous operation of a motor vehicle causing death.

It found Stevens not guilty of dangerous driving causing death on Monday at 10.49am.

Stevens had tears in his eyes as he stepped from the prisoner's dock.

Pollet, 25, was killed after being struck by the cement truck's rear tyres as the driver attempted to overtake him on Moggill Rd at Kenmore at 1.30pm on September 27, 2011.

His devastated parents Patricia and Philip Pollett said outside court they hoped their son's death would remind motorists of their duty of care to one another on the state's roads.

"We all have a duty of care to one another on the roads and we should remember that when all of us are using the roads," Philip Pollett said.

"There is an increasing number of cyclists joining the roads for health reasons and for environmental reasons and we need to exercise that duty of care, especially the drivers of heavy vehicles and especially professional drivers who should know to give cyclists sufficient room."

Judge Michael Rackemann thanked the jury for their efforts during the hearing but told the court he had been left with an "empty feeling".

"It is such an empty feeling in this case because we'd all like to do something to relieve the hurt," he said.

"I can only hope that everyone involved and their families can somehow come to peace in their hearts."

Pollett was a talented violinist and at the time of his death was in Brisbane to play as a soloist with the Queensland Symphony Orchestra.

His peers established the Richard Pollett Memorial Award with the Australian Youth Orchestra to honour his memory and to provide support and encouragement to young violinists after his death.

During the trial, the jury was told Stevens had been driving inbound when he attempted to overtake Mr Pollett in the far left-hand lane of Moggill Rd.

Crown prosecutor Michael Lehane said scratches, gouge marks and "body scuff marks" were found by officers from the Boondall Forensic Crash Unit as far back as 25m from the place where Mr Pollett's body came to rest.

The court heard the force of the impact shattered Mr Pollett's bike helmet. It was told his body had to be disentangled from his mangled bike.

He said Mr Pollett was "vulnerable" as a cyclist and any contact with a vehicle would have obviously "significantly imperilled his life".

Mr Lehane told the jury a heavy vehicle could be more difficult and take longer to manoeuvre.

"The accused should have had an appreciation for how vulnerable Mr Pollett was and insight into how unsettling his vehicle could be," he said.

Mr Lehane argued the road conditions, the vulnerability of Mr Pollett and the restricted capabilities of the heavy vehicle he was driving, should have led Stevens to "put his foot on the brake" as he approached the cyclist.

Barrister Steve Zillman, for Stevens, told the jury his client was going about his lawful business and driving in a responsible way on the day of the accident.

He said Stevens was not driving erratically or speeding and was effectively "boxed in" by other cars as he approached Mr Pollett on his bike.

Mr Zillman said Stevens was under "the honest and reasonable belief" there was enough room on the road to safely overtake him.

He cited the evidence of eye-witness Maxwell Roy Clothier, which contended that Mr Pollett may have come into contact with the cement truck near to the intersection with Blacon St - a straight section of road before the left-hand bend - and therefore "had the option" of turning down it if he felt unsafe.

Mr Zillman said there was no evidence the truck caused Mr Pollett to come off his bike and he could have fallen off as a result of "any number of reasons".

"It's not good enough to say it's a coincidence," he said.

The jury heard Moggill Rd was narrow, winding and the width of the left-hand lane expanded and reduced between 3.1m and 3.6m near to the accident scene, without signage notifying motorists of the change.


View the original article here

Thứ Sáu, 26 tháng 4, 2013

Bayley pleads not guilty to 12 charges

Adrian Ernest Bayley

Adrian Ernest Bayley appeared in court via video link. Source: Supplied

ADRIAN Ernest Bayley has pleaded not guilty to 12 charges relating to alleged sex offences in the St Kilda area.

Bayley, 41, appeared in Melbourne Magistrates' Court via video link today.

He verbally pleaded "not guilty" as Magistrate Gerard Lethbridge read out the charges to him.

Bayley has been charged with five counts of rape, three of false imprisonment and intentionally causing injury and a single count of making a threat to kill.

Bayley is accused of carrying out sex offences in the St Kilda area, dating back to 2000.

He has pleaded not guilty to all charges.

He forewent his right to a committal hearing at Melbourne Magistrates’ Court and will appear for a directions hearing in the County Court on May 21, when a trial date will be set.


View the original article here

Thứ Hai, 15 tháng 4, 2013

Mother guilty of prostituting daughter

A BRISBANE mother has become the first to be convicted under Australia's child trafficking laws.

The woman pleaded guilty in the Brisbane Supreme Court to 20 offences including child trafficking, prostituting her own daughter, and five indecent treatment of her own child under 12.

The woman, who cannot be named, also pleaded guilty to four counts of maintaining a sexual relationship with a child.

The Thai-born mother, now aged 41, first brought her daughter to Australia from Thailand for a six week holiday in 2004 during which she sold her 9-year-old daughter for sexual purposes.

Prosecutor Todd Fuller said the mother ran a massage and prostitution business from her Runcorn home on Brisbane's southside.

He said in August 2006 the girl left Thailand to live with her and immediately put her to work providing sexual services.

The court was told the mum advertised her then 11-year-old to clients as the "new girl'' and coerced her to do in and out calls as a sex worker until September 2011.

Mr Fuller said the mother even had plans to market her daughter's virginity to prospective clients with the expectation of marrying her off for financial gain.

The court was told the mum sexually exploited her daughter over a seven-year period.

Mr Fuller said the mum claimed she brought her daughter to Australia to give her a better life.

Barrister Andrew Boe, for the mum, said: "This is not a cause were a child was used as a drawcard ... to a prostitution business."

He said it was also not a case were a child had been stolen away from their family and sold into a life of servitude.

Justice Boddice, in response the submissions, said: "Mr Boe, don't insult intelligence.''

"The child was brought to Australia for that purpose (of sex worker) ... twice, not just once.''


View the original article here

Thứ Năm, 28 tháng 3, 2013

Ex-bouncers guilty of double murder

FORMER security workers Vladimir 'the Russian' Garcia and Cameron Andrew Stewart have been found guilty of the brutal murders of husband and wife Alexander and Sue Davie.

The Davies were found murdered on May 5, 2009 in two separate locations.

Mr Davie was found in a toilet cubicle of a Burleigh business he had been patrolling.

His hands were tied behind his back with zip ties, he had been beaten, stabbed 10 times and the word "dog" was written in blood on the stall door.

Mrs Davie was located on the bed in their Robina home, beaten with a hammer and stabbed.

The jury went out to deliberate at 11.45am Wednesday and returned with the verdict about 11am Thursday.

In 2006, Stewart and Cameron were employed by SSS Security, until Mr Davie, their employer, accused them of stealing guns.

Later the same year both men spent six months in remand for an unrelated crime, for which they blamed Mr Davie.


View the original article here

Thứ Năm, 21 tháng 3, 2013

Not guilty, Jurrah turns to footy

Liam Jurrah not guilty

An emotional Liam Jurrah celebrates after a jury found him not guilty of seriously harming his cousin during a wild brawl at a town camp just outside Alice Springs. Picture: Chloe Geraghty Source: Northern Territory News

FORMER Melbourne forward Liam Jurrah says he dreams of returning to the AFL after he was today found not guilty of assaulting his cousin with a machete during a brawl near Alice Springs last year.

Jubilant scenes erupted outside the Northern Territory Supreme Court in Alice Springs as the jury returned a unanimous verdict of not guilty to a charge of unlawfully causing serious harm to his cousin Basil Jurrah at the Little Sisters town camp in March last year.

The jury's verdict - after almost eight hours of deliberation over two days - prompted emotional scenes as family and friends flocked around the former Melbourne star as he walked from court a free man.

A clearly-relieved Jurrah said it remained his "dream" to return to elite football, after he was delisted by Melbourne last year.

"Yes, that is my dream ... it's very important to make my family happy again," Jurrah said.

Liam Jurrah not guilty

Liam Jurrah and supporter celebrate his not guilty verdict outside Alice Springs court. Picture: Chloe Geraghty

"I'll probably be heading back to Adelaide now to see where I'm at ... I'm feeling pretty happy right now."

Jurrah, the high-flying footy star who faced down 14 years jail - and won

Jurrah said he was confident the jury would acquit him of the charge in a trial that stretched through almost nine days of evidence, summing up and jury deliberation.

He said he was going to "lay low and enjoy the rest of my day with my family", adding that he hoped the feud that led to the brawl last year would now be finished.

Liam Jurrah not guilty

Liam Jurrah celebrates the jury's not-guilty verdict outside Alice Springs court. Picture: Chloe Geraghty

Jurrah's lawyer Jon Tippett QC applauded the not-guilty verdict.

"We said he was not guilty in the beginning and this jury has spent a long time examining the evidence and concluded that's right - he's not guilty," Mr Tippett said.

"They had a fair bit of evidence and material to go through ... so they were a conscientous group of people and as the judge said, they did the community proud, they did themselves proud and we know the system works well."

Mr Tippett said the 24-year-old, who was the first initiated Aboriginal man to play AFL, had gone through an extremely tough year since the charges were laid against him.

Liam Jurrah

Liam Jurrah at Port Adelaide pre-season training. Picture: Sarah Reed.

"I just admire him ... he is as tough as nails but inside, it's a different story," Mr Tippett said.

"It's been extraordinarily tough ... this young man has had a hell of a lot riding on his shoulders and this is just the culmination of a lot of it, it's the sort of stuff that I wouldn't want to happen to me.

"It's cross-cultural, and we have a hell of a lot of expectations of him, his Aboriginal community and family have great expectations of him, and we have put a lot on his plate."

Mr Tippett said he hoped Jurrah could rekindle his AFL career.

"I would love to see him (play again) - I've seen him play and he is pure magic, he is an extraordinary athlete.

"He's an honest man, the one thing in this case is that he told the police what happened. Ultimately the jury had regard for that because he was the only person who described his circumstances as opposed to five witnesses who said he'd done it ...

"His integrity must have played heavily on the jury's mind, he is a person of integrity and when you speak to him you feel that and he is the sort of person who will lead his community, he's just got a lot of weight on his shoulders."

The former Demons forward admitted he was present at the fight between two feuding family groups but claimed he was trying to stop the violence and took no part in the attack upon his 37-year old cousin, who suffered serious head injuries including a fractured skull.

Jurrah was facing a maximum penalty of 14 years' prison if convicted of the assault, however the jury was unanimous in its decision to acquit him of the charge.


View the original article here

Thứ Năm, 7 tháng 3, 2013

Sica found not guilty of child's rape

CONVICTED triple murderer Massimo "Max" Sica has been found not guilty of raping and repeatedly abusing a young girl over a four year period.

Sica - who is already serving a record 35-years in jail for the 2003 murder of the Singh siblings - is the latest in a growing list of reviled convicted criminals - including infamous pedophiles Dennis Ferguson and Roy Schloss - to be a acquitted after a rare judge only trial.

Brisbane District Court judge Michael Shanahan delivered the verdict to a stunned packed court - including Sica's parents Carlo and Anna and his siblings - on Friday morning.

Judge Shanahan deliberated almost two weeks before handing down his verdict 21 sex offences - including child rape.

Sica received three life terms of imprisonment - an"d ordered to serve a minimum of 35-years - for the savage murder of the Singh siblings Neelma, 24, Kunal, 18, and Sidhi, 12.

Judge Shanahan, in his written 50-page decision, said medical evidence revealed the girl physically showed all the hallmarks of being a virgin and could not have been subjected to the sexual attack alleged.

"There is one fact ... which causes me significant concern," he said.

"Considering the medical evidence I cannot be satisfied beyond a seasonable doubt that the penetrative (sexual) acts occurred as described by the (girl)."

Judge Shanahan also commented on the girl's "credibility", saying her evidence raised a "number of issues of concern."

"I am not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that any of the counts have been proved ... (and) verdicts of not guilty are entered to each of the counts."

Sica, who stood ramrod straight in the dock of Court 31 for the verdict, breathed out deeply and smiled as he heard Judge Shanahan's decision.

Outside court, Sica's jubilant brother, Claudio, said: "Justice has finally been served, but not fully."

"There was no other verdict that could have been given."

Sica has become the latest in a growing long line of infamous criminals to win judge only trials - including notorious pedophiles Dennis Ferguson and Roy Schloss.

Sica was granted the judge-only trial after his lawyers convinced the court Sica's notoriety would make it almost impossible to find and impartial panel of jurors anywhere in Queensland.

Sica early last month pleaded not guilty to 21 sex offences, including two counts of rape and one of maintaining a sexual relationship with the child between November 15, 2004 and September 10, 2008.

Then aged 35 to 39, he was also charged with nine counts each of unlawful carnal knowledge and indecent dealing of a child under 16.

The court had been told Sica allegedly had sex with the child, then aged between nine and 13, more than 100 times during the four-year period.

In July, a Brisbane Supreme Court jury found Sica guilty of the 2003 murder of the Singh siblings.

He was sentenced to three life terms, with a record minimum non-parole period of 35-years.

Sica has appealed those verdicts, with a two day hearing scheduled to start in the Court of Appeal in Brisbane on May 27.


View the original article here