Hiển thị các bài đăng có nhãn trial. Hiển thị tất cả bài đăng
Hiển thị các bài đăng có nhãn trial. Hiển thị tất cả bài đăng

Thứ Ba, 14 tháng 5, 2013

Morcombe trial will go ahead 'this year'

Justice on hold

DANIEL Morcombe; and what public prosecutors are paid in Victoria compared with Queensland. Source: The Courier-Mail

QUEENSLAND'S chief justice says he has been reassured the trial of the accused killer of schoolboy Daniel Morcombe is being dealt with promptly.

Daniel was 13 when he went missing while waiting for a bus on the Sunshine Coast in December 2003.

Brett Peter Cowan, 43, was committed in February to stand trial for Daniel's abduction and murder.

Chief Justice Paul de Jersey has reportedly said the case will not be heard until next year because the office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) lacks resources.

But Justice de Jersey issued a statement on Tuesday denying he was critical of Attorney-General Jarrod Bleijie and the Director of Public Prosecutions.

He says he has spoken to them and been reassured that Cowan's trial is proceeding "regularly".

"The present reassurance is that the Cowan matter will be dealt with regularly, and with a promptness which other jurisdictions probably could not deliver," Justice de Jersey said.

He said if a pre-trial application were made, a common feature of major criminal proceedings, the matter should be able to go ahead before the end of the year.

Parents of murdered boy Daniel Morcombe , Denise and Bruce Morcombe in their garden at the home on the Sunshine Coast

Denise and Bruce Morcombe

The government had provided the Supreme Court with additional resources, including the appointment of an additional judge last year, he said.

Mr Bleijie says he has no doubt Cowan will be before the courts by the end of the year.

"They are on track to deliver the indictment by the required time, and that's August this year, and that will proceed to a pre-trial," he told reporters in Brisbane on Tuesday.

"We actually will see, in one form or another, this matter go before the courts before the end of this year."

Mr Bleijie said the government would like the matter to proceed to trial as soon as possible.

But the DPP needed time to gather evidence so it could prosecute properly.

"It's important at this stage that I, as attorney-general, don't step over the boundaries in terms of telling the DPP how to run their office," he said.

"At this point in time the director has assured me directly he believes the resources are adequate to address these upcoming trials."

Mr Moynihan released a statement on Tuesday afternoon saying 100 per cent of cases were being heard within a statutory time frame.

"My office has the resources necessary to prosecute the matters listed for hearing," Mr Moynihan said.

Earlier today, it was reported that the case against Daniel Morcombe's accused murderer had been delayed until next year because the office of the Director of Public Prosecutions doesn't have enough experienced lawyers.

Queensland Chief Justice Paul de Jersey has told The Courier-Mail the case against Brett Peter Cowan could have been heard this year, but the office lacked the resources.

Queensland's Office of the DPP has an operating budget of about $40 million. In comparison, the NSW office spends almost $70 million on salaries alone.

Senior Crown prosecutors in Queensland are paid up to $125,000 a year, a fraction of what they could make in the private sector and about a third of what their Victorian and NSW counterparts earn.

Lawyer shortfall prolongs grief for Morcombes

The news has infuriated the lawyer for the Morcombes, who lost their son in 2003.

It has equally angered the lawyer representing Cowan, who is on remand.

Speaking about the Supreme Court's capacity to work through criminal cases but stressing he was not being critical of the State Government or DPP Tony Moynihan, Justice de Jersey said it was "desirable" for cases to come on quickly.

"We could have heard the Morcombe/Cowan trial in the Supreme Court this year but the resources at the DPP were not adequate," he said.

"They didn't have enough senior prosecutors to be able to deploy them into the Cowan trial to come on this year (and) it will come on next year.

"In principle, criminal trials should come on, after committal, within months rather than years.

"Ideally, the DPP should be resourced so that can happen. But I accept the reality that public resources are limited . . . and how they are ultimately deployed is the Government's call."

Bruce and Denise Morcombe's lawyer Peter Boyce said this was another blow for the grieving parents.

Cowan's lawyer Tim Meehan said he wrote to the Crown this month asking when it planned to present an indictment.

"Brett, he wants to have a trial. He was prepared for this year, as were we," Mr Meehan said. "(The delay) is just not good for anyone. It's certainly not good for Mr and Mrs Morcombe and their family and my client and his family."

Attorney-General Jarrod Bleijie this morning said he had spoken "directly" to the Director of Public Prosecutions Tony Moynihan, who had assured him there were adequate resources in his office to conduct the matters.

"Under the law, the DPP has until August this year to present an indictment," said Mr Bleijie outside the Queen Elizabeth II courts this morning.

"They're on track to present an indictment by August then the process will be the pre-trial hearing, then you'll have the trial.

"We will actually see in one form or another, this matter go before the courts in the pre-trial and indictment phase before the end of the year."

He said it was not his place to direct the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions but he empathised with Bruce and Denise Morcombe.

"I do empathise with them because these delays can cause hurt to the families, but I do say there are processes in place," Mr Bleijie.

"I rely on the advice from the director (Mr Moynihan) and he's assured me he's got adequate resources."

For more than a decade The Courier-Mail has reported under-resourcing at the state's prosecution body amid fears of a "brain drain".

Earlier this year, the ODPP paid private Barrister Peter Davis, QC, to prosecute the case against former Bundaberg Base Hospital surgeon Jayant Patel. When the not-guilty verdict was handed down, Mr Davis was already in another court representing Gerard Baden-Clay, who is accused of murdering his wife.

A spokesman for Mr Moynihan would not comment on claims of under-resourcing.

"The ODPP has a statutory obligation to present indictments within six months of committal. These obligations will continue to be met," he said.

Attorney-General Jarrod Bleijie said he was assured the ODPP was adequately funded.

"Mr Moynihan has indicated he has sufficient prosecution staff to deal with the current workload," Mr Bleijie said.

There are 70 crown prosecutors and about 25 are of principal crown level or above.

Criminal lawyer Bill Potts said there would only be two or three crown prosecutors who would have the skills to handle the complexity and high-profile nature of the Morcombe case.

He estimated if the ODPP outsourced the matter it would cost about $60,000 a week for up to four months.

DPP shortfall prolongs grief for Morcombes

THE lawyer representing the parents of Daniel Morcombe is frustrated by the delay in the case against the man accused of the teen's murder.

Nambour solicitor Peter Boyce said Bruce and Denise Morcombe needed closure but it was being delayed by a lack of resources at the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions.

"Bruce and Denise just want this to be finished," Mr Boyce said. "It's really difficult to move on when the most significant part of the process, the trial, is still to come."

Brett Peter Cowan, 43, was charged with Daniel's murder in August 2011 and in February this year, he was committed to stand trial.

Chief Justice of the Supreme Court Paul de Jersey said the matter could have been brought on this year but the DPP did not have an available senior prosecutor to try the matter. It will now be heard next year.

Under the Criminal Code, the ODPP has until August 6, 2013, to present an indictment in the Supreme Court.

While it is likely an indictment will be presented by this date, the case will not be heard until next year because pre-trial work will be required, and an available senior prosecutor will be needed.

The Morcombes have been left frustrated with the justice system in the past.

It was only in November that Daniel's remains were returned to his family after State Coroner Michael Barnes ordered their release. Bone fragments identified as belonging to Daniel were found at a search site at the Glass House Mountains in August 2011.

A formal bid for their release began in August when Mr Boyce applied to the Coroner.

Mr Barnes made the decision to release the bones after Cowan signed a three-page document stating he did not require the remains for his defence. 


View the original article here

Thứ Ba, 7 tháng 5, 2013

Murder trial for parents of 'starved' twins

PARENTS charged with the starving murder of their 18-month old twins almost five years ago will face trial in July.

The mother, 34, and the twins' 33-year-old father will stand trial on two counts each of murdering the toddlers, a boy and a girl, and for failing to provide them with the necessities of life on July 22.

Crown prosecutor Michael Byrne SC told a trial review in the Brisbane Supreme Court on Wednesday he expected the hearing to run for at least two weeks and possibly three.

He told Supreme Court Justice Peter Lyons he expected a psychiatric defence would be raised on behalf of the children's mother.

Mr Byrne said expert witnesses would be called to give evidence at the trial, including a general practitioner, pathologist, paediatrician and psychiatrists.

Barrister Soraya Ryan, on behalf of the toddler's mother, said she would seek a pre-trial direction relating to the Crown's particularisation of the murder charge levelled at her client.

Mr Byrne said he expected the half-day pre-trial hearing would examine how the Crown would particularise when the "intent" to murder was formed in the lead-up to the children's deaths.

It is alleged the twins were starved to death at the couple's home on Brisbane's southside between December, 2007 and 2008.

At a committal hearing in the Brisbane Magistrates Court in November, 2009, it was revealed the decomposed bodies of the toddlers were found on June 16, 2008.

A post-mortem examination found they died of malnutrition and weighed just 3.6kg and 4kg.

It heard the children lived at the small single-storey home with the couple and their three brothers and a sister - aged between three and 11 - at the time of their deaths.

The couple cannot be named under Queensland law to protect the identities of their children.


View the original article here

Thứ Hai, 25 tháng 3, 2013

Adrian Bayley's trial date set

Adrian Ernest Bayley

Adrian Bayley's trial over the alleged murder of Jill Meagher will start in September. Source: Supplied

Video evidence shown to the court allegedly shows Adrian Bayley's movements over three days from a laneway, to an out-of-town petrol station and a suburban carwash.

Jill Meagher

Jill Meagher and her husband Tom on their wedding day in 2008. Source: Herald Sun

THE man accused of killing Jill Meagher has been ordered to stand trial a week after the first anniversary of her death.

At a Supreme Court directions hearing this morning Justice Geoffrey Nettle set down the trial to start on September 30, eight days after the anniversary of Ms Meagher’s murder on September 22.

The court heard the trial could last up to three weeks and is expected to be completed before October 30, what would have been Ms Meagher’s 31st birthday.

Bayley appeared via video link from Melbourne Assessment Prison for this morning's brief hearing.

The 41-year-old has pleaded not guilty to murder and two charges of rape.

He has pleaded guilty to a single count of rape.

The court heard up to 25 witnesses could be called to give evidence during the trial.


At a committal hearing last month the court heard Bayley "accosted" Ms Meagher in the early hours of September 22 before dragging her into a Brunswick laneway where it is alleged he raped and strangled her.

The court heard he left Ms Meagher’s body there before returning home where he collected a spade and his white Holden Astra.

Prosecutors allege less than three hours later he returned to the Brunswick lane, put Ms Meagher's body into the boot of the car and drove to Gisbourne where he buried her.

Ms Meagher’s family were not in court for today’s proceedings.

Phone was vital clue in tracking suspect

Jill Meagher's life in pictures

The search for Jill ends in tragedy


View the original article here

Thứ Hai, 4 tháng 3, 2013

Dale trial witness tells of tipoff to Carl

Paul Dale

Former Victoria Police detective Paul Dale. Source: Herald Sun

A SECRET gangland witness says a former detective tipped off gangland killer Carl Williams that a drugs lab he was linked to was being watched by police.

But the prosecution witness in the trial of former detective Paul Dale today denied a suggestion he was a “thoroughly untrustworthy human being”, despite having admitted to the jury he was a gun supplier and drug dealer who was a one-time criminal associate of Williams.

The witness, who can only be referred to as Witness B, told the trial via video link from prison that the underworld was not “Mary Poppins school” and that “people who lived by the sword died by the sword”.

Under examination by Crown prosecutor Christopher Beale, SC, Witness B said Williams had told him a policeman named Paul was providing him with information about surveillance.

Witness B said the alleged information seemed “pretty good”.

It was alleged that Mr Dale was the officer being referred to, and that he warned Williams that police were carrying out surveillance on a particular drug lab that Williams was connected with.

Carl taken from jail to meet woman

Trial hears of cop sex with barrister

Letters from Carl's killer 

Witness B told the court that Williams was told to distance himself, and if he did he would not be arrested.

During cross-examination, defence counsel Geoffrey Steward established that Witness B had never met or spoken with Mr Dale and had never heard Mr Dale speak a word to Williams.

Witness B admitted to having supplied guns that were used to kill people and to “prodigious” drug trafficking.

When asked if he knew how many murders Carl Williams was responsible for, Witness B replied: “A fair few.”

He said he believed his former associate was linked to the murders of Jason Moran, Mark Moran, Mark Mallia, Nik Radev, Lewis Moran and an attempted murder and a conspiracy to murder, and that Williams had admitted to having had Graham “The Munster” Kinniburgh killed because he believed Kinniburgh had the means to have him murdered.

Mr Dale is accused of lying to the Australian Crime Commission about his relationship with Carl Williams.

He has pleaded not guilty to 12 charges relating to answers he gave while being questioned in March 2007 and November 2008.      

In his opening address, Mr Beale said Mr Dale had told ACC examiners his relationship with Williams had consisted of two planned meetings and an accidental encounter, each of which had been documented.

But Mr Beale alleged Mr Dale had an "ongoing, secret relationship'' with Williams, and had lied to the ACC because he believed he was suspected of involvement in the murder of police informer Terry Hodson and his wife, Christine.

Carl’s father, George Williams, last week told the court that he had driven his son to two secret meetings with a man he believed was Mr Dale.

He said one rendezvous was in the suburb of Hillside; the other was a 10-minute meeting at a suburban leisure centre, to which Carl took $6000.

Mr Williams said Carl later told him he'd been provided with ``swimming trunks'' and that he and Mr Dale walked in the pool -- an act Carl found amusing.

Today, Witness B agreed that Carl Williams had been a liar to certain people, a cheat, a man interested almost exclusively in himself and a big-noting multiple killer.

The witness denied suggestions that he himself was a dishonourable man.

The trial, before Justice Elizabeth Curtain, continues.

paul.anderson@news.com.au 


View the original article here